The “calm down” set fancy themselves professional and sober-minded, a tasteful levee protecting the marvel of our civilization from the uninformed and hysterical masses.
The “calm down” person’s business is business as usual.
They defend the status quo with a practiced rueful resignation: “Believe me, I wish things were different too, but it’s just the way things are.” Only “the way things are” is on a historic and murderous losing streak.
They love to second guess the “strategies” of those who are trying to actively change or challenge the “way things are.”
LEVER TIME PREMIUM: Norman Solomon On America’s Invisible Wars
David Sirota sits down with activist and journalist Norman Solomon to discuss America’s secret wars. This segment is for paid Lever subscribers only.
“Isn’t that kind of approach counterproductive?” the “calm down” type will ask.
They worry anger or a more direct approach will turn off their friends, like the “don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good” lady or the “don’t let the horrible be the enemy of the atrocious” guy.
When you express alarm about how rapidly the climate is warming, the “calm down” crowd will correct you with the most remedial facts. They believe that for you to be so bothered when they are not, there must be a fundamental misunderstanding on your part.
“You do know the global warming temperature is taken from a multiyear average, not single extreme heat events, right?” they will say, like a bemused uncle gently letting the kids know that elephants don’t actually talk like they do in story books.
“Yes, I know. But is it possible these extreme heat events, because of the rapid rate of change, even if only lasting for months or weeks, could trigger other thresholds if —”
But they’ve already moved on.
The “calm down” crowd does not have time for questions in response to their answers.
After all, their answers have been approved by the large extended crowd of “calm down” friends, consultants, business leaders, journalists, politicians, pundits, financial analysts, and media personalities with whom they routinely lunch and work.
Their pronouncements rise above the din and clink of a downtown or uptown, or an across-the-bridge restaurant that used to be a school or a hospital with a name like “Waif” or “32 Defunct”:
“It’s a slam dunk.”
“Free trade creates value for everyone.”
“The models show the housing market has always been stable.”
“Market-based health care is the achievable solution for right now.”
“When it comes to climate, we’re actually doing a lot.”
“The models show this temperature spike is only an anomaly.”
God forbid you point out to the “calm down” guy the numerous conflicts of interest and moral hazards that have constellated around him or her for the past 30 years, a spirograph of wrong turns and straight up disasters his “calm down” crowd has cheered and supported.
Dark and soft money, advertising revenue, speaking fees, future jobs, board seats, university endowments, awards, hiring preferences, social media reach, financial markets, poll numbers, and on and on.
Economies form like barnacles on a ship’s hull these days, with so much money throwing its weight around every waking and sleeping moment.
How can the “calm down” expert not see this?
But be careful. Because by mentioning any of this you are committing the greatest sin there is for the “calm down” crowd: stating the obvious.
So adverse is this group to stating the obvious that after a while, “the obvious” or the “semi-obvious” pretty much never gets stated at all.
The oil industry and their attendant financial institutions’ almost preposterous hold on the government and its elected officials?
An economic system that has nurses paying a higher functional tax rate than billionaires?
A world climate plan that after hundreds of forums, treaties, and “net-zero pledges,” still saw emissions reach their highest levels ever this past year?
All of it risks not only upsetting the “calm down” guy’s well-developed delicate late-twentieth-century aesthetic taste, but worst of all, it might just get “the people” riled up or in the worst of all possible outcomes, actually demanding change and accountability.
Learn All Our Investigative Tricks
Score a copy of our Citizens’ Guide to Following the Money and Holding the Powerful Accountable, free with a paid subscription. The e-book gives you all the tools and tricks our reporting team uses to scrutinize power.
Freak storms, fires, mass inhalation events, and megadroughts?
“A troubling look into our climate future,” the “calm down” expert intones, with vague ideas of a three-part series and who knows, maybe an award or two, running through his mind in an instant.
“But it’s all happening right now at the same time,” you say, scratching your head with an almost manic fervency.
“It’s happened before. Winter tornados, El Niño, droughts. Let’s not overreact,” he says or posts or op-edifies. “Calm down.”
And it is then that you realize this perfectly smooth stone of a person will get a lot of people killed. And after it happens, they will let us all know there was no way anyone could have ever known.